What is Sustainable Metallurgy?

Sustainable metallurgy aims to transform metal production, use, and recycling from one of the largest global emission sources into a central climate-mitigation technology by redesigning feedstocks, processes, and alloys to avoid greenhouse gas emissions and waste before they occur.

Metals account for roughly 40% of all industrial greenhouse gas emissions, about 10% of global energy consumption, and several billion tonnes of mining waste and by‑products every year. The mission of sustainable metallurgy is to decouple the enormous societal benefits of metals from this environmental burden by establishing fossil‑free, circular value chains for structural and functional alloys. This requires disruptive reductions in CO₂ emissions along the whole chain—from ore or waste feedstock through synthesis, processing, use, and end‑of‑life treatment—rather than incremental efficiency improvements on the existing carbon‑based route.

​

Metals are unique because they can, in principle, be recycled indefinitely with only limited property degradation, making them central to any realistic climate‑neutral industrial system. However, even under ideal circularity, at least one‑third of future metal demand must still be supplied from primary resources, since current and near‑future demand exceeds available scrap by about two‑thirds, so sustainable metallurgy must simultaneously reinvent primary, secondary, and tertiary (re‑mining) metal production.

Each year more than 2 billion tonnes of metals are produced, with steel, aluminum, and a few base metals dominating emission and energy budgets. Steel alone emits roughly 3.7 Gt CO₂ per year at about 2 t CO₂ per tonne of steel, while primary aluminum production emits about 1 Gt CO₂ per year at roughly 14–22 t CO₂ per tonne of metal when powered by fossil electricity. Critical energy metals such as nickel and cobalt can exceed 20 t CO₂ per tonne, reflecting both energy‑intensive reduction and complex hydrometallurgical refining.

At the same time, materials underpin a global market on the order of 3500 billion € per year, with a daily turnover of about 3.5 billion € in the EU alone, making structural and functional alloys key economic drivers. Green technologies intensify this link: producing a unit of electricity from wind or solar typically requires 200–300% more metals (on a copper‑equivalent basis) than a fossil‑fired plant, so a rapid renewable roll‑out without clean metals risks a massive rebound in CO₂ emissions just to build the energy transition hardware.

Current metal value chains are still largely linear: ores are mined, beneficiated, reduced, alloyed, processed, used, and finally landfilled or dissipated. For mass metals like Fe and Al, roughly two‑thirds of the market volume still comes from primary mineral feedstock, with only about one‑third supplied by scrap, so the bulk of CO₂ emissions, tailings, and toxic by‑products arise in the primary segment. Pure circularity is physically impossible in the near term, because growth in metal demand and entropy‑related dispersal of elements in complex products limit achievable recycling rates, especially for minor and critical elements.

A sustainable metals system therefore combines four intertwined economy models: (i) a drastically decarbonized linear segment (sustainable primary synthesis), (ii) an expanded circular segment (scrap‑based secondary synthesis), (iii) a re‑integrative “urban mining” segment that re‑mines historical industrial residues and landfilled wastes (tertiary synthesis), and (iv) a reuse/repair segment that delays scrap generation by extending product lifetimes. Re‑mining is particularly powerful because many industrial residues, such as red mud and metallurgical slags, now contain metal concentrations up to five times higher than the original ores, turning legacy waste into high‑grade feedstock.

From a materials‑science perspective, direct metallurgical sustainability focuses on four main goals.

​

• Sustainable primary production: develop routes that extract and alloy metals from ores and re‑mined wastes using non‑fossil reductants (H₂, H‑plasma, NH₃‑derived H₂, biomass‑derived gases), electrified heating, and high‑efficiency pyrometallurgical, hydrometallurgical, and plasma processes, while minimizing tailings and hazardous by‑products.

​​

• Sustainable secondary production: maximize the use of scrap through better collection, sorting, and alloy design that tolerates higher impurity levels (“dirty alloys”), enabling high‑quality products from chemically contaminated mixed feedstock with up to ~95% lower emissions than primary production.

​​

• Substitution and alloy competition: replace high‑CO₂ or scarce alloys with more sustainable alternatives (e.g., scrap‑tolerant steels, Ni‑lean stainless steels, RE‑free magnets, high‑entropy catalysts that reduce or avoid platinum‑group metals).

​​

• Longevity and reuse: design alloys, surface states, and microstructures that maximize service life, damage tolerance, corrosion resistance, and reparability so that components avoid becoming scrap in the first place.

These goals imply a shift from chemistry‑dominated to microstructure‑dominated alloy design, where compositional space is constrained for recyclability, and performance is optimized by architecture, phase topology, and defect engineering rather than by adding ever more alloying elements.